ACT tribunal ruling reinforces modular manufacturers' responsibility for building performance

An ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal (ACAT) ruling has reinforced the obligations of modular building manufacturers to deliver buildings suitable for their intended purpose, even where the completed structure complies with agreed contractual specifications.

In Andrew v AJC Portables Pty Limited [2026] ACAT 65, decided on 26 October 2026, the tribunal found that the NSW manufacturer breached section 55 of the Australian Consumer Law by supplying a modular dwelling that failed to achieve the thermal performance required for residential occupation in Canberra.

The case involved Pamela Andrew, who contracted for the dwelling in July 2022. Following installation in 2024, Canberra’s winter conditions exposed deficiencies in its thermal performance, including ice forming on internal surfaces after overnight temperatures of minus 8°C.

Contractual compliance and fitness for purpose
The tribunal heard that Andrew discussed Canberra’s thermal requirements with AJC Portables’ sales manager before purchasing the building. Three upgrades were subsequently included in the contract: ecoglazing, air cell wrap and vinyl cladding.

However, independent thermal modelling by Light House Consulting assessed the dwelling at 5.3 stars, below the six-star energy efficiency rating applicable when the contract was signed.

AJC Portables maintained that it had supplied the building in accordance with the agreed specifications and that responsibility for obtaining local building approvals rested with the purchaser.

Senior Member Jennifer Francis rejected the argument that contractual compliance alone satisfied the consumer guarantee of fitness for purpose.

In addressing the manufacturer’s position, Francis stated:

“Were compliance with the ‘reasonably fit for purpose’ consumer guarantee to be satisfied by sole reference to delivery against the contract, it would provide no remedy additional to what is already available to the consumer from the law of contract.”

The tribunal found that Andrew had disclosed the building’s intended residential use and reasonably relied on the manufacturer’s skill and judgement.

Francis further observed:

“A reasonably prudent business would have fabricated buildings to the consistent standard required to be given approval, not fabricated to fail it.”

The tribunal awarded $17,754 in compensation for the breach of the consumer guarantee. It did not need to determine the separate contractual and misleading conduct claims.

Wider implications for prefabricated construction
In February 2026, Built Offsite reported on the High Court’s refusal to hear an appeal in Tastec Pty Ltd v Larsen, leaving intact a NSW Court of Appeal decision awarding $483,244 in rectification costs following misleading conduct associated with the substitution of specified cladding materials.

While the legal circumstances differ, the two decisions address distinct obligations in prefabricated construction. The Tastec case concerned the substitution of specified materials and the resulting measure of damages, while the ACAT ruling establishes that compliance with contractual specifications does not necessarily satisfy the consumer guarantee of fitness for a disclosed purpose.

Find the ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal HERE